In the ever-evolving landscape of documentary filmmaking, R.J. Cutler is at the forefront, igniting a compelling debate on the nature of celebrity documentaries. As a veteran filmmaker with over 31 years of experience, Cutler has skillfully tackled diverse subjects, from the intricacies of politics in The World According to Dick Cheney to the fashion world in The September Issue, and even the controversial rise of e-cigarettes in Big Vape: The Rise and Fall of Juul. With multiple Emmy awards and an Oscar nomination under his belt, Cutler’s expertise in storytelling is undeniable.
Recently, his foray into the celebrity documentary subgenre has raised questions among purists regarding the authenticity of these films. Cutler has explored the lives of some of the most recognizable names in entertainment, including Billie Eilish, Martha Stewart, Elton John, Anna Wintour, Marlon Brando, and John Belushi. Critics argue that such projects lean more towards glamorous portrayals rather than true documentaries, prompting figures like Sheila Nevins, former president of HBO Documentary Films, to question their integrity: “How honest can you really be?” she asks.
Cutler, however, defends his work passionately. “Celebrity is just another form of storytelling,” he explains, asserting that these films can possess the same depth and seriousness as traditional documentaries. “The lens, figuratively and literally, is mine,” he emphasizes, underscoring his commitment to artistic control and vision.
His latest project, Martha, featuring the multifaceted Martha Stewart, debuted on Netflix and highlights the complexities of collaboration in documentary filmmaking. Stewart, initially eager to work with Cutler, found herself navigating unexpected creative tensions. Despite her expectations for a cooperative process, Stewart described the experience as “the first showdown I have ever had on a creative project,” citing a stark lack of communication and an overwhelming number of her suggestions being vetoed.
The documentary captures Stewart’s journey as the first self-made female billionaire in America, a narrative rich with conflict and contradiction. Cutler’s insights into her life reveal a profound understanding of her story, yet the clash over creative direction raises ethical considerations about authorial intent in celebrity-focused films.
With Cutler’s extensive experience, including successful collaborations on projects like Billie Eilish: The World’s a Little Blurry and Elton John: Never Too Late, he has proven adept at creating compelling narratives that resonate with audiences. In fact, Billie Eilish was acquired by Apple TV+ for an impressive $27 million, reflecting the growing demand for celebrity narratives that blend entertainment with emotional depth.
Looking ahead, Cutler’s production company, This Machine Filmworks, is actively developing a robust slate of projects, including a film centered on K-pop mogul Lee Soo-man and another focusing on the current World Series, demonstrating his dedication to a wide array of compelling stories.
Ultimately, R.J. Cutler invites us to reconsider the role of celebrity documentaries in the broader genre of filmmaking. “We’re not trying to chase a marketplace,” he asserts, emphasizing his belief that documentary filmmaking can be both popular and impactful. As he continues to navigate the complexities of celebrity narratives, Cutler’s work challenges us to engage with the stories of those who captivate us, sparking dialogue on authenticity, artistry, and the true essence of documentary filmmaking.
Read more: