In a candid conversation on the Rockonteurs podcast, Elvis Costello—legendary singer-songwriter known for hits like “Alison”—compared the songwriting approaches of two iconic musicians: Taylor Swift and Bob Dylan. Costello, 70, appeared on the Nov. 17 episode to discuss his 1986 album King of America, recently re-released in a deluxe edition, and reflected on how his songwriting has evolved over the years.
During the interview, Costello, who has long been revered for his lyrical prowess, noted that while songwriting can begin with deeply personal experiences, it requires a craft that goes beyond simply recounting one’s feelings. He explained that drawing from raw emotion is often the starting point for great songwriting, but it is the process of invention and craft that elevates a song into something universally relatable.
While reflecting on his creative process, Costello explained that, early on in his career, he realized he was not doing enough to engage his listeners. “All I was doing was reciting things that were happening to me,” Costello recalled. “Though that can be interesting to hear, it doesn’t necessarily engage the listener, ‘cause they don’t know what you’re talking about.”
To truly capture an audience, Costello emphasized, a songwriter needs to blend raw emotion with the “element of craft”—the ability to shape personal experiences into something more universal. He pointed to albums like Joni Mitchell’s Blue and Bob Dylan’s Blood on the Tracks as prime examples of this technique. Dylan’s Blood on the Tracks, in particular, embodies “the sense of revelation and invention” that Costello finds most compelling in songwriting.
Costello went on to praise Taylor Swift for her ability to capture both personal emotions and universal themes in her songs. Drawing parallels between Swift and Dylan, Costello remarked, “One minute, they seem to be very raw emotion, the next minute they’re clearly invention. And that keeps you guessing and that keeps things interesting.”
He acknowledged that, while many songwriters draw from their personal lives, Swift has mastered the art of ensuring her music resonates with listeners beyond her immediate experience. “She understands the necessity of taking personal experience but also ensuring her songs are relatable to her listeners,” Costello said, adding that Swift’s ability to balance personal and universal storytelling is what has made her one of the most successful and influential songwriters of her generation.
Costello also touched on how Swift’s success stems from her knack for creating songs that remain deeply personal while still connecting with a wide audience. “That’s why she’s able to sustain communication with her audience in quite that way,” he noted. For Costello, this is something he himself has struggled with—acknowledging that he is uncomfortable with the idea of simply turning his diary into music.
While personal heartbreak or experiences may spark a song, Costello explained that it is the aftermath—the “torturous” and sometimes “boring” repercussions—that can make these emotions feel less relatable if presented too literally. Instead, he emphasized the importance of craft in shaping those raw emotions into something that speaks to the broader human experience.
Costello’s reflections on songwriting highlight the enduring influence of artists like Bob Dylan and Joni Mitchell, who helped shape modern music by blending personal experience with invention and craft. He concluded that it is this delicate balance of emotion and artistry that continues to resonate with listeners across generations—whether it’s through Dylan’s Blood on the Tracks, Mitchell’s Blue, or Swift’s chart-topping hits.
In the end, Costello’s insights reaffirm the timelessness of songwriting that transcends personal experience, proving that the most memorable songs are those that are at once deeply personal and universally relatable.
Read more: